๐ Advantages & Idols
Season 16: Micronesia
Ozzy Lusth (Day 14, Ep 5)
Ozzy found the Hidden Immunity Idol on Exile Island and crafted a fake idol (a stick wrapped in a napkin) to replace it. He was blindsided by the Black Widow Brigade on Day 27 (Episode 10, 'I Promise...') in a 5-4 vote with the real idol still in his pocket. One of the most iconic blindsides in Survivor history.
Jason Siska (Day 19, Ep 7)
Jason found the fake idol (stick) that Ozzy had planted on Exile Island and genuinely believed it was real. He gave it to Eliza Orlins, who immediately recognized it as fake ('It's a f***ing stick!'). Eliza played it at Tribal Council on Day 24 (Episode 9) to expose that Ozzy had the real idol. Jeff confirmed it was not a real idol. This is one of the most memorable moments in Survivor history.
Jason Siska (Day 28, Ep 10)
After Ozzy's elimination, the idol was re-hidden on Exile Island. Jason found the real idol on a subsequent Exile visit. However, he was lulled into a false sense of security by the Black Widow Brigade, who promised he was safe. He chose not to play it at Tribal Council on Day 30 (Episode 11) and was blindsided in a 4-3-1 vote while holding the genuine idol in his pocket.
Amanda Kimmel (Day 31, Ep 12)
Day 31, Episode 12
For: Amanda Kimmel
4 votes negated
Amanda found the re-hidden idol on Exile Island just before Tribal Council in Episode 12 ('I'm Gonna Fix Her!'). She played it on herself at Tribal Council on Day 31, negating 4 votes cast against her. With the votes nullified, the remaining votes sent Alexis Jones home instead. This was the only successful idol play of the season.